Technical analysis: Choosing between KNX IP Interface or KNX IP Router in system design?
- KNX Vietnam
- 5 hours ago
- 6 min read
In KNX control architecture, selecting the right interfacing device between the TP (Twisted Pair) infrastructure and the IP (Ethernet) infrastructure is a pivotal decision, directly impacting data flow stability and system scalability. Practical implementation shows that many entities still confuse the tunneling and routing functions of these devices. This leads not only to inaccuracies in budget estimation but also to technical issues such as telegram conflicts or network congestion on the backbone. The following article provides an in-depth analysis of the technical specifications and optimal application scenarios for these two device categories.
1. KNX IP Interface and the KNXnet/IP Tunneling protocol
The KNX IP Interface allows for programming and connecting to the KNX bus over IP infrastructure. It supports direct tunneling connections, and most modern IP Interfaces facilitate multiple simultaneous connections.
Về bản chất, KNX IP Interface đóng vai trò như một cầu nối giữa KNX bus và mạng IP (bao gồm mạng nội bộ LAN hoặc Internet). Bằng cách kết nối các thiết bị KNX vào mạng IP, người dùng có thể truy cập và điều khiển hệ thống từ xa thông qua máy tính, điện thoại thông minh hoặc máy tính bảng, với điều kiện được cấp quyền truy cập và đảm bảo các giao thức bảo mật.
In essence, the KNX IP Interface acts as a bridge between the KNX bus and the IP network (including local area networks - LAN or the Internet). By integrating KNX devices into an IP network, users can remotely access and control the system via computers, smartphones, or tablets, provided that the necessary access permissions and security protocols are in place.
In other words, the KNX IP Interface serves as an access point that allows IP-based peripheral devices to connect to the KNX TP system.
Operating Principle: The device utilizes the KNXnet/IP Tunneling protocol. Within this process, KNX telegrams are encapsulated into UDP (User Datagram Protocol) packets for transmission across the IP network.
Connection Limits: Each Interface is typically limited to a specific number of tunneling channels (usually between 1 to 5 simultaneous connections). Each of these connections requires its own unique physical address.
Transmission Characteristics: This device does not possess the capability to automatically route data between different Lines or Areas. It serves merely as an "end-point" or "end-device" that facilitates system configuration via ETS software or enables connections to higher-level management systems (BMS/Smart Server).
KNXnet/IP Tunneling
An IP tunnel is a network communication channel based on the Internet Protocol (IP) that connects two different networks. It is used to transport another network protocol by means of an encapsulation mechanism for its packets.
KNXnet/IP Tunneling is the most common method for interfacing with a KNX system. This protocol enables the establishment of point-to-point communication, also known as unicast transmission, from a single peripheral device to the KNX system.
This is the simplest form of IP communication within the KNX ecosystem and is highly straightforward to implement, as it only requires directing the peripheral device to the specific IP address of the KNX IP Interface. Once connected, you can monitor the entire bus traffic and communicate directly with individual devices — for instance, when using the ETS software for programming. This is also the standard method utilized by external management systems to interact with the KNX network.
Applications
The KNX IP Interface is a pivotal component in modern building automation systems. This device enables remote monitoring and control of KNX devices, integrates with peripheral systems, and optimizes the overall management of building functions. When deploying a KNX-standard system, it is of paramount importance to select the appropriate interfacing solution that meets specific requirements and to implement robust security measures to protect the network.
In summary, the KNX IP Interface is primarily utilized for two main purposes:
Integrating the KNX system with third-party controllers: Establishing a seamless communication link for external control systems to interact with the KNX network.
Setting up an environment for ETS software: Enabling system programming and configuration via the IP protocol through a dedicated tunneling interface.
2. KNX IP Router and the KNXnet/IP Routing (multicasting) protocol
Similar to the IP Interface, the KNX IP Router allows for programming and connecting to the bus system; however, the core difference lies in its ability to link different segments of the KNX system via IP infrastructure. The device achieves this by utilizing an additional multicast connection and managing KNX telegram traffic through a filter table — functioning much like a traditional Line Coupler. Notably, this Multicast connection can also be leveraged as a bus interface for programming and connecting peripheral devices.
When integrating with KNX, third-party systems will use one of two methods: a tunneling connection (supported by both IP Interfaces and IP Routers) or a multicast connection (exclusively supported by IP Routers). Due to this flexibility, we generally recommend using a KNX IP Router for complex integrated systems to ensure maximum compatibility with all connection methods.
The KNX IP Router combines the capabilities of an Interface with the functionality of a coupler (Line/Area Coupler) over IP infrastructure.
Operating Principle: In addition to tunneling, the device supports the KNXnet/IP Routing protocol based on a multicast mechanism. Telegrams are broadcast to a common multicast group address (default: 224.0.23.12), allowing all other IP Routers within the same network segment to receive and process the data.
Routing and Filter Table: The core feature is the ability to manage traffic through a filter table. The device analyzes the destination address of each telegram and decides whether to permit the data to pass through. This optimizes the bandwidth for each individual line and prevents telegram flooding (signal congestion).
IP Backbone: Allows for the complete replacement of KNX TP cables on the main backbone with CAT6 network cabling.
KNXnet/IP Routing
KNXnet/IP Routing utilizes a multicast transmission mechanism, allowing a KNX IP device to function as a coupler between the TP bus and the IP infrastructure. This implies that the entire KNX system's backbone can be built on an Ethernet foundation, providing maximum flexibility during installation.
Unlike Unicast, Multicast is a group-oriented connection method. Instead of using individual IP addresses for each device, all devices on the network point to a standard Multicast address. This mechanism ensures that all telegrams are "visible" to every KNX IP device sharing the same address configuration. The KNX Association has designated 224.0.23.12 as the default Multicast address; however, technicians may use any address as long as it is synchronized across all devices in the system.
Application
The KNX IP Router is primarily utilized to connect two or more Lines or Areas to establish communication across an IP Backbone. Previously, this task was handled by Line Couplers operating purely on TP networks. Currently, the transition to IP Routers allows for the transmission of higher telegram traffic and greater flexibility in building control.
Functions when utilizing an IP Router as a Line Coupler (LC) or Backbone Coupler (BC)
System scalability: The ability to extend an existing KNX system beyond building boundaries via LAN and WAN connections.
Direct data forwarding: Enabling KNX data to be sent directly to every network node within the system.
Flexible remote configuration: Supporting access and configuration of the KNX system from any network access point.
High compatibility: Can be flexibly deployed for both new construction projects and existing KNX installations.
Bus traffic reduction via filter tables: The device automatically determines which telegrams are permitted to pass or are blocked based on the filter table. This optimizes bandwidth and prevents data collisions. The ETS software automatically generates this filter table during the configuration and commissioning process.
Automatic role assignment: Once a Physical Address is assigned, the ETS software automatically defines the coupler's function (Area: 1 – 15; Line: 1 – 15).
3. Technical specifications comparison
Specifications | KNX IP Interface | KNX IP Router |
Supported protocols | KNXnet/IP Tunneling | KNXnet/IP Tunneling & Routing |
Communication | Unicast (Point-to-Point) | Multicast (One-to-Many) |
Role in topology | End-device | Line/Area Coupler |
Filter Table | No | Yes |
Line connectivity | Need server | Automatic via IP Backbone |
Individual address (IA) | 1 IA for device + n IA for Tunnel | 1 IA for device + n IA for Tunnel |
4. Practical applications based on project scale
Case A: Apartments, villas, and townhouses (single-line topology)
For apartment or villa projects with a limited number of devices (typically fewer than 3 line segments), the KNX IP Interface is a highly recommended choice. The primary objective here is to provide a connectivity gateway for control apps or for engineers to perform ETS programming. Utilizing a router in this scenario is technically redundant and offers no added value in terms of system performance.
Case B: Buildings or multi-zone projects (multi-line/area topology)
For office buildings, hotels, or large complexes, the KNX IP Router is mandatory.
Utilize IP Routers to interconnect floors (Lines) via the building's LAN infrastructure (IP Backbone).
Leverage Filter Tables to isolate transmission faults: If a Line on the 5th floor experiences signal interference, the IP Routers will prevent this noise from affecting other floors.
Network Requirements: The IT infrastructure (Switches/Routers) must support IGMP Snooping to efficiently manage Multicast data streams and prevent paralyzing the standard local area network.
-02.png)
Comments